An automation ROI estimate compares the value of a changed workflow with the cost of building and operating it. Include review, exceptions, and maintenance rather than counting only the seconds saved by the automated step.
This worksheet is a planning model. Its output depends on your assumptions and does not establish that estimated time value will become cash savings.
Record the inputs
Use a consistent period, such as one month:
- Number of tasks.
- Manual minutes per task.
- Automated workflow minutes per task, including review.
- Additional monthly maintenance time.
- Hourly value used for planning.
- Monthly software and operating cost.
- One-time setup cost.
Keep the source of each estimate beside it. Replace guesses with observations as the pilot runs.
Calculate the net time change
Monthly manual hours = Tasks × Manual minutes ÷ 60
Monthly assisted hours = Tasks × Assisted minutes ÷ 60 + Maintenance hours
Net hours saved = Manual hours − Assisted hours
A negative result means the proposed workflow takes more time under the stated assumptions.
Work through an illustrative example
Assume 100 tasks per month, 12 manual minutes per task, and 5 assisted minutes including review. Maintenance takes 2 hours monthly.
- Manual time: 100 × 12 ÷ 60 = 20 hours.
- Assisted time: 100 × 5 ÷ 60 + 2 ≈ 10.33 hours.
- Net time saved: approximately 9.67 hours.
These are fictional inputs, not a benchmark.
Estimate value separately from cash savings
At an assumed €25 per hour, 9.67 hours represents approximately €241.67 of time value. Subtracting €40 monthly operating cost leaves approximately €201.67 of modeled monthly net value.
If setup costs €600, simple payback is:
€600 ÷ €201.67 ≈ 2.98 months
This assumes steady volume, comparable quality, and the same ongoing cost. Payback is not meaningful when the modeled monthly net value is zero or negative.
Calculate a defined first-year return
For this simplified model:
First-year return = (12 × Monthly net value − Setup cost) ÷ Setup cost × 100
The example gives approximately 303.3%. This is a time-value-based estimate, not an audited financial return.
If you are measuring actual cash ROI, use realized cash benefits and costs instead. Do not treat freed employee time as a payroll reduction unless that reduction really occurs.
Test less favorable assumptions
Recalculate with lower task volume, longer review time, and more exceptions. Also consider the cost of errors and the effect on response quality.
A workflow that looks attractive only under the most optimistic scenario needs more evidence before expansion.
Decide what to measure in the pilot
Track actual task duration, correction rate, maintenance time, and completed work. Record important failures even when they are rare.
Use the worksheet to compare an observed process with a proposed one. If the assumptions cannot be explained, the apparent precision of the result is not useful.
